Free Write While Writing Bad Romance
So as I wrote Bad Romance: A Look at How Twilight Connects to Literacy and Domestic Abuse I kept getting really really frustrated and angry, so I would take a moment to have a little free write, then do something else to calm down. It worked well. You may find my fits of anger humorous, so here you go, extra special just for you:
----
This is SO HARD to write about, because every time I try to take a step back and be academic, I can't. I am so disgusted by this book, so angered by what she portrays. Bella, an empty shell of a human, there to be abused, held up as a role model? The mentally and sometimes physically abusive Edward, upheld as oh-so dreamy? Stalking romantic? What are we teaching young women besides that not okay relationships are okay? Every time I think about this, and try to write it in a scholarly fashion, I get too upset. I can't step back and do that, I want to fill it with emotion, and speak directly to Angel's little sisters, and other middle school and high school kids, and say "This is not okay, you deserve better than that. You don't ever need some one else to validate you, or run your life. You are you, and that is independent, and wonderful, as long as you believe it, and treat yourself right."
I would rather have my daughter dress like Julia Roberts in Pretty Woman for Halloween and be having responsible sex at 16 than in an abusive relationship like this. Because I would want my baby girl to be confidant in who she is, and what she's about. I want her to, even if she makes some bad decisions (ie: dress like a tramp and have sex in high school) be able to stand strong, and know that her family loves her in a healthy, caring way, and be able to walk away if anyone treats her wrong. (Not that I would be happy with her dressing like a tramp and having sex so young, but if I was told I had two choices for what my daughter would be like at 16? That would be the one to pick, over blank slate and stalker McGee.)
This is so hard to write about calmly, when I know it is wrong. The Anger I feel for knowing this is being treated as okay and even good, and fear I feel for the young woman who will take this to heart. The fear for myself, to be in a society that might move backwards because abuse is acceptable. there is a distinct wrongness about this that is being treated as right, and it is not okay.
FUUUUUUUUUCK I am too angry to not be preachy. THIS IS NEVER OKAY. YOU ARE ALWAYS WORTH MORE. YOU HAVE WORTH BEYOND WHAT A MAN GIVES YOU. YOU ARE ALLOWED TO BE HAPPY IN YOUR OWN RIGHT, INDEPENDENT OF OTHERS. TEAM BELLA GROWS A BACKBONE AND REALIZES SHE DOESN'T NEED A MAN. Okay, I think I'm done with that now. Also. Why does she ignore her Father? Charlie obviously loves her and cares about her, even if he doesn't know what he's doing, and how could he, if she's been living in Phoenix? He'd trying, he cleaned up, and had her room ready, he bought her a car, he wants to encourage her to make friends and have a social life, and all she does is belittle his efforts! What the hell! He's a guy, he grew up a guy, he lives as a guy, he is as far from being a teenage girl you can get without being DEAD. He will never understand or be able to help if you do not help facilitate a dialogue! My own father, who has raised two girls to adulthood, STILL does not always get it, but he tries, and he can't open the dialogue all the time, if I want something, I HAVE TO ASK. If I want to spend time with him, I talk to him! It isn't magic, Mom might get most of the secret girl subtle signs, but Daddy will only ever get about a third of them, if he's lucky. He's a guy. He can try, and try he has, but he will only get so much. Imagine if he had never raised us, if we just moved in when we were 16, having only come a few summers before puberty. He'd have no fucking clue. Give the man a break, and have a proper relationship with your Daddy. No WONDER she is fucked up about dudes.
---
Thank you, the end. Essay to come.
----
This is SO HARD to write about, because every time I try to take a step back and be academic, I can't. I am so disgusted by this book, so angered by what she portrays. Bella, an empty shell of a human, there to be abused, held up as a role model? The mentally and sometimes physically abusive Edward, upheld as oh-so dreamy? Stalking romantic? What are we teaching young women besides that not okay relationships are okay? Every time I think about this, and try to write it in a scholarly fashion, I get too upset. I can't step back and do that, I want to fill it with emotion, and speak directly to Angel's little sisters, and other middle school and high school kids, and say "This is not okay, you deserve better than that. You don't ever need some one else to validate you, or run your life. You are you, and that is independent, and wonderful, as long as you believe it, and treat yourself right."
I would rather have my daughter dress like Julia Roberts in Pretty Woman for Halloween and be having responsible sex at 16 than in an abusive relationship like this. Because I would want my baby girl to be confidant in who she is, and what she's about. I want her to, even if she makes some bad decisions (ie: dress like a tramp and have sex in high school) be able to stand strong, and know that her family loves her in a healthy, caring way, and be able to walk away if anyone treats her wrong. (Not that I would be happy with her dressing like a tramp and having sex so young, but if I was told I had two choices for what my daughter would be like at 16? That would be the one to pick, over blank slate and stalker McGee.)
This is so hard to write about calmly, when I know it is wrong. The Anger I feel for knowing this is being treated as okay and even good, and fear I feel for the young woman who will take this to heart. The fear for myself, to be in a society that might move backwards because abuse is acceptable. there is a distinct wrongness about this that is being treated as right, and it is not okay.
FUUUUUUUUUCK I am too angry to not be preachy. THIS IS NEVER OKAY. YOU ARE ALWAYS WORTH MORE. YOU HAVE WORTH BEYOND WHAT A MAN GIVES YOU. YOU ARE ALLOWED TO BE HAPPY IN YOUR OWN RIGHT, INDEPENDENT OF OTHERS. TEAM BELLA GROWS A BACKBONE AND REALIZES SHE DOESN'T NEED A MAN. Okay, I think I'm done with that now. Also. Why does she ignore her Father? Charlie obviously loves her and cares about her, even if he doesn't know what he's doing, and how could he, if she's been living in Phoenix? He'd trying, he cleaned up, and had her room ready, he bought her a car, he wants to encourage her to make friends and have a social life, and all she does is belittle his efforts! What the hell! He's a guy, he grew up a guy, he lives as a guy, he is as far from being a teenage girl you can get without being DEAD. He will never understand or be able to help if you do not help facilitate a dialogue! My own father, who has raised two girls to adulthood, STILL does not always get it, but he tries, and he can't open the dialogue all the time, if I want something, I HAVE TO ASK. If I want to spend time with him, I talk to him! It isn't magic, Mom might get most of the secret girl subtle signs, but Daddy will only ever get about a third of them, if he's lucky. He's a guy. He can try, and try he has, but he will only get so much. Imagine if he had never raised us, if we just moved in when we were 16, having only come a few summers before puberty. He'd have no fucking clue. Give the man a break, and have a proper relationship with your Daddy. No WONDER she is fucked up about dudes.
---
Thank you, the end. Essay to come.
angry
anxious
cold
drained
sick
blah